| Survivor: Panama — Exile Island | |
|---|---|
Survivor: Panama - Exile Island Logo |
|
| Genre | Reality television |
| Winner | Aras Baskauskas (5-2) |
| No. of episodes | 15 |
| No. of days | 39 |
| No. of survivors | 16 |
| Tribes | Casaya La Mina Bayoneta Viveros Gitanos |
| Fans vs. Favorites | Cirie Fields |
| Heroes vs. Villains | Danielle DiLorenzo, Cirie Fields |
| Production | |
| Location(s) | Pearl Islands, Panama |
| Filming dates | October 31, 2005 – December 9, 2005 |
| Broadcast | |
| Original run | February 2, 2006 – May 14, 2006 |
| Chronology | |
| Preceded by | Survivor: Guatemala |
| Followed by | Survivor: Cook Islands |
Survivor: Panama — Exile Island, also known as Survivor: Exile Island and Survivor: Panama, is the twelfth season of the American CBS competitive reality television series Survivor. The season was filmed in the Pearl Islands, off the coast of Panama. This location was previously used for Survivor: Pearl Islands and Survivor: All-Stars. Filming began on October 31, 2005 and the season premiered on February 2, 2006 on CBS. The season finale was on May 14, 2006 with the votes revealed live from the Ed Sullivan Theater in New York.[1]
Applications were due on June 17, 2005. Around August 2005, 800 applicants were invited for an interview by CBS. Out of these 800, 48 of them were selected as semi-finalists and they invited to Los Angeles in September 2005. From these semi-finalists, 16 were chosen the show and filming took place in November to December 2005.
The season included a twist that originally came from Survivor: Palau called Exile Island. Each week at least one castaway is banished for the time period between the reward challenge and the immunity challenge on Exile Island. The exile is given a single machete, a flint, a pot and a bucket of non-sanitized water. The island also contained a hidden immunity idol that could be used at tribal council after the votes have been cast. This gave the person who found the idol a strategic advantage because that person can keep the idol secret until he or she was voted off, which would cause the person with the second largest number of votes to be eliminated. As it developed, Terry found the idol and never needed to use it at a vote, but his possession of it appeared to influence how several other people voted.
The game began by splitting the 16 players into four tribes by sex and age: young men (Viveros, green buffs), older men (La Mina, orange buffs), young women (Bayoneta, blue buffs) and older women (Casaya, purple buffs). These four tribes were named after four islands located in the Pearl Islands. During the second episode the Viveros and Bayoneta tribes were dissolved and in a "schoolyard pick" with only Casaya and La Mina making two new integrated tribes. The 10 remaining contestants merged into one tribe, and called their new tribe Gitanos (black buffs, located at the former Casaya camp), the Spanish word for "gypsy." Coincidentally, a member from each of the original four tribes was represented in the final four.
Tina Scheer was originally slated for Survivor: Guatemala, but she backed out due to her son's death prior to that show.[2]
On June 8, 2006 Survivor: Panama was made available on Apple's iTunes store.
In a 5-2 vote, Aras Baskauskas defeated Danielle DiLorenzo to take the $1 million prize.
Cirie Fields was selected from this season to compete in Survivor: Micronesia as part of the Favorites tribe and placed third. Fields competed again in Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains as part of the Heroes tribe, where she placed 17th. Danielle DiLorenzo also competed on Heroes vs. Villains as part of the Villains tribe, placing 7th.
Although a DVD release of the season has not yet been planned, Amazon.com is currently giving its customers the option to sign up to be notified when the item becomes available.
The game began with the 16 competitors split into four tribes by both relative age and gender. They were introduced to the concept of "Exile Island" with the promise of a hidden immunity idol located somewhere on it, while one person from the losing tribe at challenges would be sent to the island and given clues to look for it. After the first four days, the four tribes were merged by schoolyard pick with mixed genders into two tribes, Casaya and La Mina. Casaya generally proved the stronger tribe, and opted to send Terry from La Mina over to Exile Island multiple times, which gave him the opportunity to discover the hidden immunity idol.
Going into the merge, Casaya was up 6 members to 4. While Terry won several individual immunities, he did not use it or the hidden immunity idol to save his former La Mina tribe members, leaving him as the sole remaining La Mina member and a perceived immunity challenge threat by the other Casaya tribe. Bruce was evacuated due a medical emergency, leaving six players at the game. At this juncture, Cirie, who saw both Terry and Shane looking separately to take Courtney, a weaker player, into the final Tribal Council as an assurance to win the jury's favor, convinced Aras and Danielle to blindside the other three, and succeeded in achieving Courtney's elimination. Shane was eliminated after the next two tribal councils, and the final four vote came down a fire-making tiebreaker between Cirie and Danielle; Danielle ultimately won. Danielle won the final immunity challenge and opted to take Aras to the final Tribal Council, eliminating Terry. The final jury saw both Aras and Danielle as capable players but ultimately voted Aras as sole survivor, five votes to two.
| Contestant | Original Tribe | Absorbed Tribe | Merged Tribe | Finish | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tina Scheer 44, Hayward, WI |
Casaya | 1st Voted Out Day 3 |
3 | ||
| Melinda Hyder 32, Nashville, TN |
Casaya | Casaya | 2nd Voted Out Day 6 |
5 | |
| Misty Giles 24, Dallas, TX |
Bayoneta | La Mina | 3rd Voted Out Day 8 |
5 | |
| Ruth-Marie Milliman 48, Greenville, SC |
Casaya | La Mina | 4th Voted Out Day 11 |
6 | |
| Bobby Mason 32, Los Angeles, CA |
Viveros | Casaya | 5th Voted Out Day 14 |
3 | |
| Dan Barry 51, South Hadley, MA |
La Mina | La Mina | 6th Voted Out Day 15 |
3 | |
| Nick Stanbury 25, Tuscon, AZ |
Viveros | La Mina | Gitanos | 7th Voted Out Day 18 |
6 |
| Austin Carty 24, Raleigh, NC |
Viveros | La Mina | 8th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 21 |
7 | |
| Sally Schumann 27, Chicago, IL |
Bayoneta | La Mina | 9th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 24 |
8 | |
| Bruce Kanegai 57, Sacramento, CA |
La Mina | Casaya1 | Removed Due to Illness 3rd Jury Member Day 25 |
2 | |
| Courtney Marit 31, Los Angeles, CA |
Bayoneta | Casaya | 10th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 30 |
4 | |
| Shane Powers 35, Los Angeles, CA |
La Mina | Casaya | 11th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 33 |
9 | |
| Cirie Fields 35, Walterboro, SC |
Casaya | Casaya | 12th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 36 |
3 | |
| Terry Deitz 46, Farmington, CT |
La Mina | La Mina | 13th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 38 |
1 | |
| Danielle DiLorenzo 24, Boston,MA |
Bayoneta | Casaya | Runner-Up | 4 | |
| Aras Baskauskas 24, Santa Monica, CA |
Viveros | Casaya | Sole Survivor | 9 |
| Episode title | Air date | Challenges | Exiled | Eliminated | Vote | Finish | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reward | Immunity | ||||||
| "The First Exile" | February 2, 2006 | La Mina | Bayoneta | Misty | Tina | 3–1 | 1st Voted Out Day 3 |
| Viveros | La Mina | ||||||
| Casaya | Viveros | ||||||
| "Breakdown" | February 9, 2006 | La Mina | La Mina | Bruce1 | Melinda | 5-2 | 2nd Voted Out Day 6 |
| "Crazy Fights, Snake Dinners" | February 16, 2006 | La Mina | Casaya | Bruce | Misty | 5-2 | 3rd Voted Out Day 8 |
| "Starvation and Lunacy" | February 23, 2006 | Casaya | Casaya | Terry | Ruth-Marie | 4-2 | 4th Voted Out Day 11 |
| "For Cod's Sake" | March 2, 2006 | Casaya | La Mina | Terry | Bobby | 3-2-1-1 | 5th Voted Out Day 14 |
| "Salvation and Desertion" | March 9, 2006 | Casaya2 | Sally2 | Dan | 3-12 | 6th Voted Out Day 15 |
|
| "A Closer Look" | March 15, 2006 | Recap Episode | |||||
| "An Emerging Plan" | March 30, 2006 | None3 | Terry | None3 | Nick | 6-4 | 7th Voted Out Day 18 |
| "The Power of the Idol" | April 6, 2006 | Aras, Bruce, Sally | Terry | Austin, Danielle | Austin | 6-3 | 8th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 21 |
| "Fight for Your Life or Eat" | April 13, 2006 | Bruce, Courtney, Sally, Terry | Terry | Aras | Sally | 6-2 | 9th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 24 |
| "Medical Emergency" | April 20, 2006 | Cirie, [Aras, Danielle] | None4 | Terry | Bruce | No Vote | Left Due To Illness 3rd Jury Member Day 25 |
| "Perilous Scramble" | April 27, 2006 | Courtney, Danielle, Terry5 | Terry | Aras | Courtney | 3-2-1 | 10th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 30 |
| "Bamboozled" | May 4, 2006 | Terry, [Shane] | Terry | Danielle | Shane | 3-1-1 | 11th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 33 |
| "Call the Whambulence!" | May 11, 2006 | Aras, [Cirie] | Aras | Danielle, Terry | None | 2-26 | |
| "The Final Showdown" | May 14, 2006 | Terry | Danielle | None | Cirie | No Vote6 | 12th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 36 |
| Terry | 1-0 | 13th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 38 |
|||||
| "Reunion" | May 14, 2006 | Jury Vote | Danielle | 5-2 | Runner-up | ||
| Aras | Sole Survivor | ||||||
^1 Bruce was not chosen by a tribe. He was sent to Exile Island and would join the tribe that loses a member. He joined Casaya after Melinda's elimination.
^2 Combined Reward and Immunity Challenge.
^3 There was no Reward Challenge due to tribal merge, therefore no one was sent to Exile Island.
^4 There was no Immunity Challenge due to Bruce's withdrawal of the game.
^5 As well as a barbecue meal, Terry won a GMC Yukon for winning the second part of the reward challenge.
^6 Cirie and Danielle were tied at Tribal Council, but before the tiebreaker challenge was shown, Episode 13 ended. At the start of the next episode, Cirie lost the fire-building tiebreaker, previously used in Palau.
All 16 castaways arrived on what was later revealed as Exile Island for the start of the game. They were divided into four tribes based on their age and gender. Then an impromptu Reward Challenge commenced. With Viveros, Casaya and La Mina victorious, the losing tribe, Bayoneta, had to pick one of their own to stay on Exile, who would return in time for the next Immunity Challenge. Through Rock, Paper, Scissors, it was decided among the younger women that Misty would remain. The older tribes fared well. Tina's leadership at Casaya helped everyone get chores done. La Mina successfully built a bonfire. However, the two younger tribes could not get anything done. At the first Immunity Challenge, Misty returned from Exile Island and pretended she found the Immunity Idol hidden there, although it was not necessary when Bayoneta finished first. The male tribes La Mina and Viveros finished second and third, and Casaya headed to Tribal Council. Back at Casaya, Tina caught a sizable fish while Ruth-Marie and Melinda targeted Cirie for being a weak link. At Tribal Council, Tina accused her tribemates about their work ethic, prompting everyone to vote her out. In the end, Ruth-Marie and Melinda sided with Cirie as the secretly grieving Tina was voted out 3-1.
Following a terrible storm, the tribes gathered for a Reward Challenge and were shocked to learn they would be rearranged. Bayoneta and Viveros were disbanded, with all remaining contestants spread across the new Casaya and La Mina tribes of seven people each. The new La Mina tribe consisted of Austin, Dan, Misty, Nick, Ruth-Marie, Sally, and Terry. The new Casaya tribe consisted of Aras, Bobby, Cirie, Courtney, Danielle, Melinda, and Shane. With Bruce left over as a result of the odd number of castaways, he was granted immunity and sent to Exile Island for three days until tribal council and would join the tribe that lost the next Immunity Challenge. The new La Mina Tribe won the Reward Challenge and was give a raft and fishing supplies. Despite quickly losing their newly acquired spear in deep water, La Mina won the Immunity Challenge as well. Before Tribal Council, Shane considered quitting because of nicotine withdrawal but his newly formed alliance of Aras, Courtney, and Danielle convinced him to get over it. At Tribal Council (with Bruce watching the proceedings on the Jury bench), the five new Casaya members ganged up on the only "Older Women" members Cirie and Melinda, with Melinda voted out in a 5-2 vote. After Melinda's demise, Bruce removed his old orange buff and was then given a new purple buff, thus officially joining Casaya and headed back to camp with them.
At Casaya, Bruce used spare T-shirts to develop a water filtration system, meaning his tribe did not need to boil the brackish water before drinking it. It proved popular with some, but Courtney met it with skepticism. La Mina won camping essentials and the right to choose which member of Casaya would be exiled at the Reward Challenge. They chose Bruce, believing that his absence would most demoralize the tribe. Shane's mood swings continued and created friction among his alliance. Casaya won their first Immunity Challenge, and back at La Mina, Dan and Terry recruited Nick and Austin to target Misty due to her poor performance in the immunity challenge combined with possibly having the hidden immunity idol. Her bluff about obtaining the Hidden Immunity Idol proved false as she was blindsided 5-2.
Before the Reward Challenge, Bruce, Aras and Shane returned from foraging for food to find the rest of their tribe had let the fire go out. After a lesson about responsibility around the campsite, they pulled together and won the Reward Challenge for bathroom and supplies, and chose to exile Terry, because they believed him to be his team's leader. Bobby created some friction with his teammates by disagreeing with how the reward should be used. La Mina tried to organize their camp, but were lost without Terry. Terry discovered the mysterious Hidden Immunity Idol (a makeshift shrunken head concealed inside a bottle), which he kept as a secret from his teammates after his return. Dan pulled in Ruth-Marie as a fifth person in his alliance, but after losing another Immunity Challenge, Sally convinced the La Mina men that she was a more valuable player. In the end, strength outweighed loyalty as Ruth-Marie was voted out 4-2.
Bruce's "Zen Garden" caused friction in Casaya and Aras felt he should instead have been helping with the daily camp chores. Incorporating the reward into the challenge, the winning tribe would receive all the items that were used in the challenge: fish, rice, spices, and wine. The losing tribe will not go back to camp empty-handed, for they were to choose either a sack of rice or a sack of beans. La Mina lost again and Casaya chose Terry to go to Exile Island for the second time in a row. As Casaya returned to camp, they found out that their shelter was ruined due to the storm that happened during the challenge. Since the storm also extinguished their fire and they were unable to create another one on account of everything being wet, they merely enjoyed what they had and ate the fish raw. Meanwhile, as La Mina ate the beans that they chose from the Reward Challenge, Austin and Nick faced the gastrointestinal consequences. The next morning at Casaya, Danielle and Courtney learned Bruce and Bobby spent the night sleeping in their outhouse, drinking all the wine they had won. At the Immunity Challenge, La Mina constructed the skull pyramid faster than Casaya, finally breaking their losing streak and winning Immunity. After the immunity challenge, Shane told Bobby that Bruce was the next to go, as his tribe feared he would flip over to La Mina's alliance come time of the merge. He assured Bobby he wasn't to go by swearing on his son's name; however, Cirie, Courtney and Danielle overpowered Shane and told him they felt Bruce was more trustworthy and less problematic. At tribal council, Shane voted for Aras as a "throwaway vote" as not to choose either side, and the women of Casaya led an erratic 3-2-1-1 vote, resulting in the elimination of Bobby.
At La Mina's camp, while Austin and the other men searched for edible creatures in the water, Dan spoke to Nick about his space flights at NASA. At Casaya, the women complained to Shane about how disrespectful he was. In a combined Reward and Immunity challenge Casaya, despite falling back early, won a barbecue and a trip to a local village, as well as the right to exile someone from La Mina. Because the losing tribe would be attending Tribal Council, Sally, the only woman left in La Mina was exiled and was granted Immunity and unable to vote. Despite being alone, she enjoyed the knowledge that her banishment would break up the men's alliance. Meanwhile, Casaya enjoyed their reward. They rode a boat to a village and gave some toys to children. Shane saw someone smoking and talked about giving up all his clothes just to smoke a cigarette. He ended up smoking after a long abstinence. Later the tribe enjoyed barbecue, played soccer, and partied. At Tribal Council, the four men discussed how tight their alliance was, and the possibility of a two vs. two tie vote. In the end, Terry sided with the younger men and Dan was voted off 3-1.
La Mina received treemail that they are to go to Casaya for the merge. Before their arrival, Shane pulled his tribe together in an agreement to vote out the other Tribe in the next four Tribal Councils. While building a larger shelter, Nick accidentally chipped Bruce's tooth with a machete, but Bruce was fine. Meanwhile, Terry tried to convince some Casaya members to flip, but no one would budge. At the Immunity Challenge, the survivors hung on a pole with their hands and feet only. Terry outlasted the other nine, winning immunity. Before Tribal Council, Bruce drew the name "Gitanos" for their new tribe name, meaning "Gypsies" in Spanish. Later that night, Nick, considered the second strongest member after Terry, was voted out along former tribal lines, 6-4.
With Nick voted out, the former La Mina tribe attempted to flip some of the Casaya tribe members. At the reward challenge, the castaways were split into three teams, and Bruce, Aras, and Sally ended up victorious. Austin and Danielle were exiled together, while the winners enjoyed a big breakfast in a rain-soaked bed. At the immunity challenge, the castaways competed in an obstacle course, with a few contestants getting eliminated in each round. Terry ended up victorious with his second individual immunity win in a row. Back at camp, the former La Mina tribe tried to convince Bruce and Danielle, the two outcasts of their alliance, to switch to the La Mina alliance. Terry offered Danielle the immunity idol in exchange for her switch. At Tribal Council, Danielle and Bruce still showed loyalty to Casaya, and, with a 6-3 vote, got rid of Austin.
After another La Mina's departure, Sally and Terry were at their most desperate to keep themselves in the game. At the Reward Challenge, the team of Bruce, Courtney, Sally, and Terry won a videos from home, peanut butter & jelly sandwiches, and ice-cold milk. They chose Aras to be sent to Exile Island. Back at the camp, a paranoid Shane told registered nurse Cirie that he was "having problems" with his testicles (and stripped naked in the process). When the winning team got back, they brought some of their reward with them. At the Immunity Challenge, the players had to decide between a feast of cheeseburgers, fries, and soft drinks or the immunity challenge. Bruce, Cirie, Courtney, Danielle, and Shane decided to feast. Whereas Aras, Sally, and Terry chose to participate. Terry narrowly defeated Aras, with Sally placing third. When the Survivors got back to camp, Sally and Terry continued their efforts to break the Casaya alliance. Despite their efforts, the Casaya alliance held strong, and Sally was voted out 6-2.
Terry seemed to become more bitter about his continued status outside of the alliance. In a Reward Challenge where the contestants voted about their fellow contestants, Courtney was shocked to learn she was considered the most unpopular of the tribe. By correctly guessing what the majority of the tribe had chosen for their answers, Cirie won the challenge and sent Terry to Exile Island taking Aras and Danielle to share her reward. Cirie then worried about what effect her decisions might have with the other players. Back at the camp, Courtney was bitter because of some of the opinions expressed in the challenge and Shane was upset because he hadn't been chosen by Cirie for the reward. Shane attempted to ally himself with Courtney, but to no avail. Bruce, who had been sick for several days, was in increasing pain. He claimed to have not gone to the toilet since the Panamanian village reward (episode 6). Finally, he couldn't take it any longer and asked for medical assistance. The medical team arrived and took him out of the game. Later that day, with the Reward winners returned, Jeff Probst brought Terry back to the camp from Exile Island and revealed that as a result of Bruce's withdrawal, there was no Immunity Challenge nor Tribal Council, and Bruce would assume a position on the Jury if his condition allowed.
The other players continued to worry about Shane's strange behavior: he had found a piece of wood and was pretending it was his BlackBerry and he was sending messages to people back home. At the Reward Challenge, Terry won a 2007 GMC Yukon, and he, Courtney and Danielle won a meal together. During their reward, Terry made a deal with Courtney and Danielle for the three of them to work together. Back at camp, Cirie went fishing and caught a sizable fish. After returning to camp, Danielle told Terry she was worried that if they were in the final three with Courtney, she figured he would pick Courtney to go to the final two with because she was less popular. Terry made an agreement with Danielle that if either of them won the final immunity challenge, they would take the second place winner to the final two. When Courtney was told of this, she became upset because she felt it implied she was being carried by other players. Terry won his fourth straight Immunity Challenge, and the former Casaya alliance was forced to vote out one of their own. Shane thought the alliance was in agreement to vote out Danielle, while Courtney thought that her new alliance with Danielle, Terry and fourth member Cirie was voting against Aras. Cirie, who didn't like her low position in this alliance formed a new alliance with Aras and Danielle to vote against Courtney. With the votes split three ways, Courtney was blindsided 3-2-1.
Players competed in a Reward Challenge of obstacles from past challenges for a visit with loved ones. The winner would decide who gets what with their loved one. Terry won and he choose himself and his wife, along with Shane and his son, Boston, to spend the night at a villa. He also chose Cirie's husband H.B. to spend the night at the camp, Aras to just get a hug from his mother and Danielle to get a few words with her mom from where she was standing. After the loved ones left, the players competed for Immunity. For the fifth time in a row, Terry won immunity. Back at camp, Aras decided to break his alliance with Shane after finding out that Shane wanted to take Courtney to the final two. Aras then made an alliance with Cirie and Danielle. In the end, Shane was blindsided in a 3-1-1 decision.
Terry was inadvertently tripped by Cirie's torch and yelled at her while she was tending the bonfire, but Aras protected her, saying that it was an accident. This left Terry further isolated among the tribe. Aras, having won the Reward Challenge, chose to take Cirie on a luxurious yacht trip through the Panama Canal; but not before leaving with a debate with Terry as he accused him for complaining every time he lose challenges and blurting out "disparaging comments about women." Both Terry and Danielle were sent to Exile Island for losing the Challenge. During their trip, Aras and Cirie made a pact for the Final 2; while Danielle and Terry also conspired for their fate in the game during their time on exile. Soon after returning from their reward, Cirie successfully built her first fire. In the Immunity Challenge, Cirie and Terry were putting up a good fight but Aras ultimately won the challenge, thus ending Terry's Immunity winning streak. Before the tribal council, Aras approached Terry to apologize for accusations of Terry's worthiness to remain in the game after Reward Challenge, which Terry accepted. Meanwhile, Cirie and Danielle practiced making fire, anticipated this would be the tiebreaker in the event of a tie (with Danielle reconsidering about Terry giving his Hidden Immunity Idol to her). In the end, the guess proved accurate as the vote indeed ended up tied between Danielle and Cirie. With Terry refusing to give Danielle the Hidden Immunity Idol, she and Cirie will partake in a fire-starting challenge. However right before they began, the scene was cut, ending this episode with a cliffhanger to be shown in the final episode.
After many attempts to start fires that continue to wear out, Danielle won the fire starting tie-breaker, and Cirie was eliminated from the game. The next morning, Terry displayed the now powerless Immunity Idol back at camp, and in a surprise Reward Challenge, he won a protein-enriched meal that would be useful for the final Immunity Challenge. The final three were taken to Exile Island to take part in a tribute to the eliminated Survivors. The three placed the extinguished torches of the thirteen eliminated Survivors on the large skull-shaped shelter in the center of the island and burned it in the process. Danielle won the final immunity after Terry fell off and Aras jumped off after receiving a nod from Danielle. Danielle voted out Terry, thinking that she would have a better chance of winning against Aras, and because Aras was a fellow member of the former Casaya tribe. With all of the older castaways gone, Aras and Danielle received a celebratory food reward the next day. While walking along the beach rocks, Aras slipped and sliced open his hand and back, requiring a total of eight stitches. At the final Tribal Council, Aras and Danielle were asked questions ranging from who contributed the most in getting them into the final two, as to why the other castaway was more deserving of the million dollar prize. Shane, who felt neither of the two were deserving of the prize, asked them to pick a number between one and a million. At the live reunion show it was revealed that Aras, in a 5-2 decision, had become the twelfth Sole Survivor.
| Original Tribes |
Absorbed Tribes | Merged Tribe | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Episode # | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | |
| Eliminated: | Tina 3/4 votes |
Melinda 5/7 votes |
Misty 5/7 votes |
Ruth-Marie 4/6 votes |
Bobby 3/7 votes |
Dan 3/4 votes |
Nick 6/10 votes |
Austin 6/9 votes |
Sally 6/8 votes |
Bruce No vote3 |
Courtney 3/6 votes |
Shane 3/5 votes |
Tie4 | Cirie No vote4 |
Terry 1 vote |
| Voter | Vote | ||||||||||||||
| Aras | Melinda | Bruce | Nick | Austin | Sally | Courtney | Shane | Danielle | |||||||
| Danielle | Melinda | Bobby | Nick | Austin | Sally | Courtney | Shane | Cirie | Terry | ||||||
| Terry | Misty | Ruth-Marie | Dan | Shane | Aras | Aras | Aras | Aras | Cirie | ||||||
| Cirie | Tina | Shane | Bobby | Nick | Austin | Sally | Courtney | Shane | Danielle | ||||||
| Shane | Melinda | Aras | Nick | Austin | Sally | Danielle | Danielle | ||||||||
| Courtney | Melinda | Bobby | Nick | Austin | Sally | Aras | |||||||||
| Bruce | Exiled1 | Courtney | Nick | Austin | Sally | ||||||||||
| Sally | Ruth-Marie | Ruth-Marie | Exiled2 | Shane | Aras | Aras | |||||||||
| Austin | Misty | Ruth-Marie | Dan | Shane | Aras | ||||||||||
| Nick | Misty | Ruth-Marie | Dan | Shane | |||||||||||
| Dan | Misty | Sally | Austin | ||||||||||||
| Bobby | Melinda | Bruce | |||||||||||||
| Ruth-Marie | Tina | Misty | Sally | ||||||||||||
| Misty | Ruth-Marie | ||||||||||||||
| Melinda | Tina | Shane | |||||||||||||
| Tina | Cirie | ||||||||||||||
| Jury vote | ||
|---|---|---|
| Finalist: | Danielle 2/7 votes |
Aras 5/7 votes |
| Juror | Vote | |
| Terry | Aras | |
| Cirie | Aras | |
| Shane | Danielle | |
| Courtney | Aras | |
| Bruce | Danielle | |
| Sally | Aras | |
| Austin | Aras | |
^1 Bruce joined Casaya after the episode 2 vote, which is why he did not cast a vote. ^2 Sally was exiled during the episode 6 vote, which is why she did not cast a vote.
^3 Because Bruce was removed due to a medical emergency, he was not voted out, and there was no tribal council.
^4 No one was eliminated during Episode 13, due to a 2-2 deadlock between Cirie and Danielle. Following the vote, Cirie lost the fire-building tiebreaker, but it was not shown until the following episode.